期刊文献+

10种中华医学会系列杂志处理医学伦理问题的调查及分析 被引量:13

A survey of ethical issues in 10 Chinese medical journals
原文传递
导出
摘要 为了解我国医学期刊论文中处理医学伦理问题的现状,查阅了10种中华医学会系列杂志2009年发表的涉及人体的研究论文,以及这10种期刊稿约中关于医学伦理方面的要求,结果不是很满意。认为作者、审稿人和编辑应认识到科研要符合医学伦理,医学论文中对此要有所说明。这些要求是符合国际规范和要求的,是人类文明的体现。 For the understanding of the current situation of ethical issues in medical journals, we analyzed all original research articles on human subjects in 10 biomedical journals published by the Chinese Medical Association in 2009. The policies of ethical issues stated in the Instructions for Authors of the 10 journals were also reviewed. The outcomes of this study were compared with related literatures. Totally, 1 033 articles were included in this survey. We found that although all the 10 journals require authors to describe ethical issues in their submissions as shown in the Instructions for Authors, the proportion of articles stating ethical issues ranged from 11.70% to 68.57% (mean 30.59% ), which was not completely satisfactory. To improve this situation, authors, reviewers and editors should realize the importance of addressing the ethical issue in research papers. These requirements are in line with international norms and are the embodiment of human civilization.
出处 《编辑学报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2011年第4期320-322,共3页 Acta Editologica
关键词 医学期刊 医学伦理 调查 biomedical journal ethical issue survey
  • 相关文献

参考文献13

  • 1中华医学会系列杂志.2009年质量评估排名表.杂志工作通讯,2009,:1-1.
  • 2Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomed- ical Journals:Ethical Considerations in the Conduct and Re- porting of Research:Protection of Human Subjects and Ani- mals in Research [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03-12 ]. http :////www. iemje, org/ethical_6protection, html.
  • 3Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals :Ethical Considerations in the Conduct and Reporting of Research: Privacy and Confidentiality [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03- 12 ]. http://www, icmje, org/ethical_Sprivacy, html.
  • 4Instructions for Authors [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03-12 ]. http :// jama. ama-assn, org/site/misc/ifora, xhtml # EthicalApprov- alofStudiesandInformedConsent.
  • 5Consent to publication [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03-12 ]. http :////re- sources, bmj. com/bmj/about-bmj/advisory-panels/ethics- committee/consent-to-publication.
  • 6Bioethics [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03 -12 ]. http: ff www. nature. com/authors/policies/bioethics, html.
  • 7General information for authors [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03-12 ]. http ://www. sciencemag, org/site/feature/contribinfo/prep! gen_info, xhtml#human.
  • 8Guides for authors [ EB/OL ]. [ 2011-03-12 ]. http : f//www. karger, com/pan_Guidelines.
  • 9Kjellstr~m S, Fridlund B. Literature review : Status and trends of research ethics in Swedish nurses' dissertations [ J ]. Nurs Ethics,2010,17:383-392.
  • 10Kjellstr~m S, Ross S N, Fridlund B. Research ethics in dis- sertations : ethical issues and complexity of reasoning [ J ]. J Med Ethics, 2010, 36:425--430 doi: 10. l136/jme. 2009. 034561.

二级参考文献22

  • 1International congress on peer review and biomedical publication.September 16-18,2005.Chicago,Illionois,USA.
  • 2Farthing MJG.Research misconduct.Gut,1997,41:1 -2.
  • 3Farthing MJG.Retractions in Gut 10 years after publication.Gut,2001,48:285-286.
  • 4Lock S.Research misconduct 1947-1990;an imperfect history.In:Lock S,Wells F,Farthing M,eds.Fraud and misconduct in biomedical research.3rd ed.London BMJ Publishing Group,2001:51 -63.
  • 5International Committee of Medical Journal Editors.Uniform requirements for manuscripts submitted to biomedical journal.2006.
  • 6White C,eds.The COPE Report 1999.Annual Report of the Committee on Publication Ethics.London:BMJ Books,1999.
  • 7Smith R.Authorship:time for a paradigm shift? BMJ,1997,314:992.
  • 8Smith R.Peer review:reform of revolution? Time to open up the black box of peer review.BMJ,1997,315:759-760.
  • 9Doherty M.The misconduct of redundant publication.Ann Rheum Dis,1996,55:83-85.
  • 10Budd JM,Sievert ME,Schults TR.Phenomena of retraction.JAMA,1998,280:296-297.

共引文献13

同被引文献92

引证文献13

二级引证文献83

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部