摘要
中国能动司法的背后具有特定的动机、目的。能动司法的动机可分为:主导动机与非主导动机、外部动机与内部动机、近景动机与远景动机,其动机特征呈现应急性和特殊性。能动司法的目的可分为:短期目的与长期目的、政治目的与法律目的、初级目的与高级目的,其目的具有短期性和政治性特征。因此,能动司法的意义是有限的。它只是提出了中国司法裁判中能动性或灵活性与确定性之间的关系问题;彰显了法律实用主义的司法观念;成为中国"大立法时代"结束及"大司法时代"到来的一个信号。中国司法的真正希望不仅在于是否能动司法,还在于是否全面、深入的司法制度改革。
The substance of Chinese judicial activism consists in specific motivation, goal. The motivation of judicial activism, which possesses the feature of emergency and particularity, can be divided into dominantive and assistant motivation, extrinsic and intrinsic motivation, proximal and distant motivation. The goal of judicial activism falls into short-term and longterm goal, political and legal goal, primary and senior goal, featured with short term and politics quality. The significance of judicial activism is limited. It only puts forward the question of relationship between activity or flexibility and certainty, manifest a legal pragmatism judicial concept, and signals the end of traditional legislation era and the arrival of judicial initiative era. The true hope of Chinese judicature lies not only in judicial activism, but also in the comprehensive and profound reform in judicial system.
出处
《浙江工商大学学报》
2011年第3期18-25,共8页
Journal of Zhejiang Gongshang University
基金
国家社会科学基金项目<司法能动与中国特色司法发展道路的探索>(10BFX050)
关键词
中国
能动司法
动机
目的
Chinese
judicial activism
motivation
goal
