换个角度看服务:从下载量看图书馆学论文的价值与需求被引量：16

Considering the Library Service in Another Point of View: Evaluating the Paper's Value and User's Interests from Number of Its Internet Downloads

下载PDF

导出

摘要文章对图书馆作者发表的论文,进行了被引次数与下载频次的比较分析,发现面向同行的学术探讨性论文,获得了高的被引频次;而基于服务职能、面向用户的指导性论文,获得了较高的下载量,但二者间没有显著的相关性。认为下载量可在一定程度上反映论文对于用户的贡献即应用价值,应该作为考量论文质量的标准之一;对下载量所揭示的用户需求,应该充分重视,鼓励服务导向的研究。 We have analyzed the top papers by download and citations published between 2000 and 2009 by librarians.It was found that library academic-oriented papers got much more citations and user service-oriented papers got high number of their Internet downloads.There is no significant correlation between Download and citations.Analysis of this comparison suggests that download frequency can reveal not only the paper＇s application value-its contributions to users,but also information of which papers are most interesting to the readers.So it should be an alternative metrics of paper quality and impact.User service-oriented study should be encouraged in the library.

作者杨春华王桂枝马红月

机构地区解放军医学图书馆

出处《图书与情报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2010年第4期100-103,111,共5页 Library & Information

关键词图书馆下载频次被引次数论文质量 library download frequency citations paper quality and impact

分类号 G250 [文化科学—图书馆学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献11

1Dan O'Leary.On the relationship between citations and appearances on "top 25" download lists in the International Journal of Accounting Information Systems[J].International Journal of Accounting Information Systems,2008,(9):61-75.
2Johan Bollen,Herbert Van de Sompel,Joan A.Smith et al.Toward alternative metrics of journal impact:A comparison of download and citation data[J].Information Processing & Management,2005,(6):1419-1440.
3Daniel E.O'Leary.The relationship between citations and number of downloads in Decision Support Systems[J].Decision Support Systems 2008,45(4):972-980.
4Editorial.Which papers are most interesting to the readers of Cardiovascular Research?[J].Information from download monitoring.Cardiovascular Research,2005,65(1):5.
5Jahandideh S,Abdolmaleki P,Asadabadi EB.Prediction of future citations of a research paper from number of its internet downloads[J].Med Hypotheses,2007,(69):458-459.
6Christos Zavos,Jannis Kountouras,Nikolaos Zavos,et al.Predicting future citations of a research paper from number of its Internet downloads:The Medical Hypotheses case[J].Medical Hypotheses,2008,70(2):460-461.
7Andrew J.S.Coats.The top papers by download and citations from the International Journal of Cardiology in 2007[J].International Journal of Cardiology,2008,(1):1-3.
8CoatsAJ.Top of the charts:download versus citations in the International Journal of Cardiology[J].Int J Cardiol,2005,105(2):123-125.
9郭强,赵瑾,刘思源,张芳,刘新新.科技论文下载次数的统计性质研究[J].情报科学,2009,27(5):690-694. 被引量：28
10[EB/OL].[2009-12-27].http://www.hflib.gov.cn/zhinan/tsgzy.php.

二级参考文献19

1张玉华,潘云涛,马峥.科技论文评估方法研究[J].编辑学报,2004,16(4):243-244. 被引量：56
2万锦堃,花平寰,孙秀坤.期刊论文被引用及其Web全文下载的文献计量分析[J].现代图书情报技术,2005(4):58-62. 被引量：82
3庞景安.中文科技期刊下载计量指标与引用计量指标的比较研究[J].情报理论与实践,2006,29(1):44-48. 被引量：44
4张洋.期刊Web下载总频次的布拉德福分布研究[J].图书情报知识,2006,23(6):38-42. 被引量：54
5Melvin Weinstock.Citation Indexes[EB/OL].http://www.garfield.library.upeun.edu/essays/V1p188y1962-73.pdf,2008-04-30.
6Frederick C.Thome.The CitaftOH Index:Another Case of Spurious Validity[J].Journal of Clinical Psychology,1977,33,(4):1157-1161.
7Daryl E.Chubin.Soumyo D.Moitra.Content Analysis of Social Studies of Science,1975,5(4):423-441.
8Michael J.Moravesik,Poovanalingam Murugesan.Some Re-salts on the Function and Quality of Cimtions[J].Social Studies of Science,1975,5(1):86-92.
9Leo Egghe,Ronald Rousseau.Introduction to Informetrics:Quantitative Methods in Library,Documentation and Irffor-mation Science[M].Amsterdam:Elsevier,1990:203-220.
10Julie A.Virgo.A Statistical Procedure for Evaluating the Im-portance of Scientific Papem[J].Library Quarterly,1977.47:415-430.