病人家属参与医疗决定之法律研究被引量：19

A Legal Analysis of Patient Family's Right to Participate in Making Medical Decisions

下载PDF

导出

摘要在我国目前的收入结构与医疗体制之下,对于大多数人而言,一旦面对大的病患风险,家属往往是其医疗成本以及医疗后果的直接承担者。当医疗决定牵涉到家庭成员的重大利益时,患者自主权应该受到家属决定权的制约。病人并非如病患自主理论所预设的前提一样是一个自由且理性的选择者,而是一个组织社群所有关系的总和,因此个人自决并不应该豁免其社群义务,尤其是对于家庭之义务。即使是成年具有意思能力病人其家属亦应具有相应的权利。 This Paper is an analysis of Patient Family's authority to participate in medical decision-making. It argues the reasons call for the participation of patient family, and suggest different mode to the different kinds of patients: competent adults, incompetent adults. First, the patients are competent adults, to harmonize patient's autonomy and patient family's interest, members of the patients' family should have a participatory role in the medical decision-making, without depriving patient's to make the ultimate decision. Second, in making decisions for incompetent adults, the patient family's principal authority should be limited by the patients' best interests.

作者储殷谭馨海

机构地区中国人民大学国际关系学院四川省社会科学院法学研究所

出处《法律科学（西北政法大学学报）》 CSSCI 北大核心 2005年第4期97-102,共6页 Science of Law：Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law

关键词家属法律研究病人医疗体制收入结构家庭成员所有关系意思能力承担者决定权自主权社群义务多数患者自由权利 autonomy of patient patient family's authority to participate in medical decision-making informed consent

分类号 D996 [政治法律—经济法学] B842.6 [哲学宗教—基础心理学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献18

1Gerald Dworkin,Can You Trust Autonomy?HASTINGS CENTER REPORT,March-April,2003.
2陈棋炎黄宗乐郭振恭.民法亲属新论[M].台北:三民书局,1999..
3Joseph H. Howell & William F. Sale, Life Choices: A Hastings Center Introduction To Bioethics, GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY PRESS/WSAHINFTON,D. C, 2000.
4Frances H. Miller How Culture and Economics Affect Informed Consent in the U. S, the U. K, and Japan, 20Am. J. L. &Med.357 - 373(1994).
5张立方.医疗与社会--医学社会学的探索[M].台北:巨流图书有限公司,2002..
6Agatha Lambris, Informed Consent for All? Not Quite! A Comparison of Informed Consent in the United States and Japan,7Femp. Int' 1 & Comp. L.J., 2003.
7Bruce Jennings & Tue Ryndes & Carol D'Onofrio &Nary Ann Baily, Access to Hospice Care: Expanding Boundaries,Overcoming Barriers,HASTINGS CENTER REPORT March- April,2003.
8陈俊宏.当代自由主义与社群主义论争的若干启示[J].(台湾)东吴政法学报,2003,(4).
9Martha Minow, All in the Family & in all Families: Membership, Loving,and Owing,95W. Va. L. Rev. 275,307,1992 - 1993.
10Leslie P. Francis,The Roles of the Family in Making Health Care Decisions for Incompetent Patients, 1992 Utah L. Rev.,1992.