摘要
对于不法原因给付,世界各国均作出了"不得请求返还"的规定,我国民法没有类似规定,司法实践中有的判决给付违法无效、财产返还,有的由人民法院根据《民法通则》规定给予没收给付财产的民事制裁措施。这里从不法原因给付的概念、构成、"给付"的效力、国外"不得请求返还"的立法理由及其争议,以及对无效返还和没收充公处理方式的评述,探求合理的解决途径,同时对我国民事制裁制度提出置疑。
As for payment by illegal causes, all the countries in the world have stated the routine 'No appeal for refund '. However, there are no similar rules in the civil law of our country. In the judicial practice some payments are announced invalid with the property returned. In otherc ases,paid property is confiscated in accordance with the General Rules for Civil Law as a measure of civil punishment. The paper tries to probe reasonable solutions through the payment concept, composition and 'payment' validity by illegal causes and the judicial causes disputes from 'No appeal for refund' abroad, and the comments on the ways of treatment of invalid return and public confiscation. Meanwhile, a question is raised about the system of the civil punishment in our country.
出处
《辽宁师范大学学报（社会科学版）》
2003年第1期16-18,共3页
Journal of Liaoning Normal University(Social Science Edition)
关键词
不法原因
给付
民事制裁措施
illegal causes
payment
civil punishing measures
