摘要
期刊年度核验制度是我国对期刊出版活动进行监管的重要手段。通过梳理我国期刊年度核验政策的历史进程,并聚焦2020—2024年度国家新闻出版署发布的期刊核验政策文本,从核验内容、核验程序、工作要求三个方面对比其年度调整特点。基于政策对比结果,从政策迭代视角揭示期刊出版监管的演进逻辑,发现其呈现出“问题精准化、责任刚性化、流程标准化”三大特征。具体体现为:坚守社会效益优先的价值导向、坚持问题导向破解行业突出问题、数字治理推动监管效能提升、构建常态化抽检制度和严格的退出机制。这一演进逻辑对于期刊出版实践具有重要指导意义。期刊出版单位及其主管主办单位要深入研读期刊年度核验政策,通过强化质量管控、规范合规经营、压实主体责任,实现期刊高质量发展。
The annual journal verification system serves as a crucial mechanism for supervising journal publishing activities in China.This system is of great significance in upholding ideological security,ensuring content quality,regulating publishing practices,and improving the publishing supervision system.It provides an institutional framework enabling Chinese journals to maximize their value in scientific dissemination,cultural preservation,and societal service.This paper first sorts out the historical progression of China's annual journal verification policies,identifying three distinct phases:initial establishment phase(1991—2004),policy standardization phase(2005—2019),and digital supervision phase(2020present).Through analysis of verification policy documents issued by the National Press and Publication Administration from 2020 to 2024,this paper compares three key dimensions—verification content,procedures,and work requirementsrevealing annual policy adjustments characterized by"refined verification content,standardized verification procedures,and enhanced work requirements."Based on this policy comparison,this paper reveals the evolutionary logic of journal publishing supervision from the perspective of policy iteration,highlighting three core features:targeted problem-solving,rigid responsibility,and standardized processes.These features manifest in several key aspects:upholding the value orientation of prioritizing social benefits;refining the supervision of journals'new media operations;implementing collaborative governance to address academic misconduct;strengthening supervision over non-compliant business practices;upgrading verification platforms to restructure supervision processes;improving data quality to provide accurate basis;for supervision;and establishing a regular sampling inspection system and a strict withdrawal mechanism.This evolutionary logic holds significant guiding significance for journal publishing practices.Journal publishing entities,along with their supervising and sponsoring entities,must thoroughly examine annual journal verification policies,proactively adapt to policy reforms,promptly optimize their internal management systems,and integrate into;policy provisions and internal management systems of journal publishing entities.By strengthening quality control,standardizing compliant operations,and consolidating their primary responsibilities,these entities can boost journal competitiveness,achieve high-quality development,thus contributing to building a socialist cultural power.
作者
古明加
戴晓玲
王景周
GU Mingjia;DAI Xiaoling;WANG Jingzhou(Editorial Department of School Journals,Party School of the CPC Guangdong Provincial Committee,510053,Guangzhou,China;School of Chinese Language and Literature,Jinan University,510632,Guangzhou,China;Journal Center,The Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University,510630,Guangzhou,China)
出处
《科技与出版》
北大核心
2025年第10期25-37,共13页
Science-Technology & Publication
基金
全国高等学校文科学报研究会2025年度编辑学研究课题“政策迭代视角下期刊出版监管的演进逻辑——基于2020—2024年度核验政策的对比分析”(PY2025183)
2024年度广东省哲学社会科学规划项目一般项目“基于语用论辩论证理论的同行评议研究”(GD24CZX02)
2024年度广东省科技计划项目“‘论文工厂’的运行机制、论文特征及治理路径研究”(2024B1212110006)。
关键词
期刊出版监管
期刊年度核验政策
政策迭代
演进逻辑
期刊出版实践
journal publishing supervision
annual journal verification
policy iteration
evolutionary logic
journal publishing practice
