A Short Review of the Vector Charmonium-Like State ψ(4230)
摘要
We present a concise review of the vector charmonium state ψ(4230), which was originally labelled as Y(4260)in the literature. As one of the earliest candidates for a quantum chromodynamics exotic states, its interpretation has initiated various ideas about possible manifestations of non-perturbative mechanisms in the charmonium mass regime. In this short article we briefly review the experimental status of ψ(4230) and discuss possible theoretical interpretations. We will focus on four broadly investigated scenarios, i.e., tetraquark, hybrid, hadro-quarkonium,and hadronic molecule, and highlight the key issues based on these approaches. Crucial experimental observables,e.g., mass position, lineshapes, di-lepton decay width Γ_(ee), production rates in B meson decays, dominant hadronic decay patterns, and the potential 1^(-+)and 0^(--)exotic partners, are assessed, which can provide crucial structure information for understanding this mysterious state.
基金
supported in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos.12375073 and 12235018)。
参考文献2
-
1K.A.Olive,K.Agashe,C.Amsler,M.Antonelli,J.-F.Arguin,D.M.Asner,H.Baer,H.R.Band,R.M.Barnett,T.Basaglia,C.W.Bauer,J.J.Beatty,V.I.Belousov,J.Beringer,G.Bernardi,S.Bethke,H.Bichsel,O.Biebe,E.Blucher,S.Blusk,G.Brooijmans,O.Buchmueller,V.Burkert,M.A.Bychkov,R.N.Cahn,M.Carena,A.Ceccucci,A.Cerr,D.Chakraborty,M.-C.Chen,R.S.Chivukula,K.Copic,G.Cowan,O.Dahl,G.D'Ambrosio,T.Damour,D.de Florian,A.de Gouvea,T.DeGrand,P.de Jong,G.Dissertor,B.A.Dobrescu,M.Doser,M.Drees,H.K.Dreiner,D.A.Edwards,S.Eidelman,J.Erler,V.V.Ezhela,W.Fetscher,B.D.Fields,B.Foster,A.Freitas,T.K.Gaisser,H.Gallagher,L.Garren,H.-J.Gerber,G.Gerbier,T.Gershon,T.Gherghetta,S.Golwala,M.Goodman,C.Grab,A.V.Gritsan,C.Grojean,D.E.Groom,M.Grnewald,A.Gurtu,T.Gutsche,H.E.Haber,K.Hagiwara,C.Hanhart,S.Hashimoto,Y.Hayato,K.G.Hayes,M.Heffner,B.Heltsley,J.J.Hernandez-Rey,K.Hikasa,A.Hocker,J.Holder,A.Holtkamp,J.Huston,J.D.Jackson,K.F.Johnson,T.Junk,M.Kado,D.Karlen,U.F.Katz,S.R.Klein,E.Klempt,R.V.Kowalewski,F.Krauss,M.Kreps,B.Krusche,Yu.V.Kuyanov,Y.Kwon,O.Lahav,J.Laiho,P.Langacker,A.Liddle,Z.Ligeti,C.-J.Lin,T.M.Liss,L.Littenberg,K.S.Lugovsky,S.B.Lugovsky,F.Maltoni,T.Mannel,A.V.Manohar,W.J.Marciano,A.D.Martin,A.Masoni,J.Matthews,D.Milstead,P.Molaro,K.Monig,F.Moortgat,M.J.Mortonson,H.Murayama,K.Nakamura,M.Narain,P.Nason,S.Navas,M.Neubert,P.Nevski,Y.Nir,L.Pape,J.Parsons,C.Patrignani,J.A.Peacock,M.Pennington,S.T.Petcov,Kavli IPMU,A.Piepke,A.Pomarol,A.Quadt,S.Raby,J.Rademacker,G.Raffel,B.N.Ratcliff,P.Richardson,A.Ringwald,S.Roesler,S.Rolli,A.Romaniouk,L.J.Rosenberg,J,L.Rosner,G.Rybka,C.T.Sachrajda,Y.Sakai,G.P.Salam,S.Sarkar,F.Sauli,O.Schneider,K.Scholberg,D.Scott,V.Sharma,S.R.Sharpe,M.Silari,T.Sjostrand,P.Skands,J.G.Smith,G.F.Smoot,S.Spanier,H.Spieler,C.Spiering,A.Stahl,T.Stanev,S.L.Stone,T.Sumiyoshi,M.J.Syphers,F.Takahashi,M.Tanabashi,J.Terning,L.Tiator,M.Titov,N.P.Tkachenko,N.A.Tornqvist,D.Tovey,G.Valencia,G.Venanzoni,M.G.Vincter,P.Vogel,A.Vogt,S.P.Wakely,W.Walkowiak,C.W.Walter,D.R.Ward,G.Weiglein,D.H.Weinberg,E.J.Weinberg,M.White,L.R.Wiencke,C.G.Wohl,L.Wolfenstein,J.Womersley,C.L.Woody,R.L.Workman,A.Yamamoto,W.-M.Yao,G.P.Zeller,O.V.Zenin,J.Zhang,R.-Y.Zhu,F.Zimmermann,P.A.Zyla,G.Harper,V.S.Lugovsky,P.Schaffner.PARTICLE DETECTORS AT ACCELERATORS[J].Chinese Physics C,2014,38(9):413-443. 被引量:3
-
2陈莹,邱伟峰,宫明,桂龙成,刘朝峰.Exotic vector charmonium and its leptonic decay width[J].Chinese Physics C,2016,40(8):11-19. 被引量:2
二级参考文献240
-
1Experimental Techniques in High Energy Physics, T. Ferbel (ed.) (Addison-Wesley, Menlo Park, CA, 1987).
-
2K. Kleinknecht, Detectors for Particle Radiation, Cambridge University Press (1998).
-
3G.F. Knoll, Radiation Detection and Measurement, 3nd edition, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1999).
-
4D.R. Green, The Physics of Particle Detectors, Cambridge Monographs on Particle Physics, Nuclear Physics and Cosmol-ogy, # 12, Cambridge University Press (2000).
-
5C. Leroy & P.-G. Rancoita, Principles of Radiation Interaction in Matter and Detection, (World Scientific, Singapore, 2004).
-
6C. Grupen, Particle Detectors, Cambridge Monographs on Particle Physics, Nuclear Physics and Cosmology, Cambridge University Press (2008).[Icarus Collab.], [CARUS-TM/2001-09] LGNS-EXP 13/89 add 2-01.
-
7H. Spieler, IEEE Trans. NS29, 1142 (1982).
-
8K. Arisaka, Nucl. Instrum. Methods A442, 80 (2000).
-
9K.K. Hamamatsu, Electron Tube Division, Photomultiplier Tubes: Basics and Applications, 3rd edition (2006).
-
10Can be found under "Photomultiplier Tube Handbook" at http://sales.hamamatsu.com/assets/applications/ETD/ pmt.1landbook/.pmt.1landbook_complete. pdf.
共引文献3
-
1谭志云,杨友昌,万猛,田维钊.多夸克系统中的湮灭相互作用与新强子态X(3872)研究[J].西南大学学报(自然科学版),2017,39(5):145-149.
-
2Chengjun Xia,Zhenyu Zhu,Xia Zhou,Ang Li.Sound velocity in dense stellar matter with strangeness and compact stars[J].Chinese Physics C,2021,45(5):237-246. 被引量:1
-
3Chang-Zheng Yuan.Charmonium and charmoniumlike states at the BESIII experiment[J].National Science Review,2021,8(11):22-34. 被引量:1
-
1Chenran Xu,Jichen Zhou,Zhexu Shan,Wenjian Su,Kenji Watanabe,Takashi Taniguchi,Dawei Wang,Yanhao Tang.Valley-selective manipulation of moiréexcitons through optical Stark effect[J].Chinese Physics B,2025,34(1):14-18.
-
2Xian-Wei Kang,Jin-Zhe Zhang,Xin-Heng Guo.Nature of X(3872)from recent BESIII data:considering the universal feature of an S-wave threshold resonance[J].Chinese Physics C,2025,49(7):59-65.
-
3Hong-Wei Ke,Xiao-Hai Liu,Xue-Qian Li.Study on the possible molecular state composed of D^∗sD^¯s1 within the Bethe-Salpeter framework[J].Chinese Physics C,2020,44(9):40-52.
-
4Nelson R.F.Braga,Yan F.Ferreira,William S.Cunha.Holography and the internal structure of charmonium[J].Chinese Physics C,2025,49(8):73-86.
-
5Yun-Hua Chen,Zi-Wei Li.Chromopolarizability of charm-beauty quarkonium from B_(c)(2S)→B_(c)ππtransition[J].Communications in Theoretical Physics,2025,77(7):92-97.
-
6Xiang Liu.Four-charm-quark matter from the CMS collaboration as a witness of the development of high-precision Hadron spectroscopy[J].Science Bulletin,2024,69(18):2802-2803.
-
7Zhi-Lei Ma,Zhun Lu,Hao Liu,Li Zhang.Inelastic heavy quarkonium photoproduction in p-p and Pb-Pb collisions at LHC energies[J].Chinese Physics C,2025,49(10):114-133.
-
8Shenglong Xu,Congjun Wu.Orbital-active Dirac materials from the symmetry principle[J].Quantum Frontiers,2022,1(1):199-213.
-
9Liang Yuhao,Lin Shu.Spin alignment of quarkonia in vortical quark-gluon plasma[J].Chinese Physics C,2025,49(8):249-262.
-
10M.Ablikim,M.N.Achasov,P.Adlarson,O.Afedulidis,X.C.Ai,R.Aliberti,A.Amoroso,Y.Bai,O.Bakina,I.Balossino,Y.Ban,H.-R.Bao,V.Batozskaya,K.Begzsuren,N.Berger,M.Berlowski,M.Bertani,D.Bettoni,F.Bianchi,E.Bianco,A.Bortone,I.Boyko,R.A.Briere,A.Brueggemann,H.Cai,X.Cai,A.Calcaterra,G.F.Cao,N.Cao,S.A.Cetin,X.Y.Chai,J.F.Chang,G.R.Che,Y.Z.Che,G.Chelkov,C.Chen,C.H.Chen,Chao Chen,G.Chen,H.S.Chen,H.Y.Chen,M.L.Chen,S.J.Chen,S.L.Chen,S.M.Chen,T.Chen,X.R.Chen,X.T.Chen,Y.B.Chen,Y.Q.Chen,Z.J.Chen,Z.Y.Chen,S.K.Choi,G.Cibinetto,F.Cossio,J.J.Cui,H.L.Dai,J.P.Dai,A.Dbeyssi,R.E.de Boer,D.Dedovich,C.Q.Deng,Z.Y.Deng,A.Denig,I.Denisenko,M.Destefanis,F.De Mori,B.Ding,X.X.Ding,Y.Ding,Y.Ding,J.Dong,L.Y.Dong,M.Y.Dong,X.Dong,M.C.Du,S.X.Du,Y.Y.Duan,Z.H.Duan,P.Egorov,Y.H.Fan,J.Fang,J.Fang,S.S.Fang,W.X.Fang,Y.Fang,Y.Q.Fang,R.Farinelli,L.Fava,F.Feldbauer,G.Felici,C.Q.Feng,J.H.Feng,Y.T.Feng,M.Fritsch,C.D.Fu,J.L.Fu,Y.W.Fu,H.Gao,X.B.Gao,Y.N.Gao,Yang Gao,S.Garbolino,I.Garzia,L.Ge,P.T.Ge,Z.W.Ge,C.Geng,E.M.Gersabeck,A.Gilman,K.Goetzen,L.Gong,W.X.Gong,W.Gradl,S.Gramigna,M.Greco,M.H.Gu,Y.T.Gu,C.Y.Guan,A.Q.Guo,L.B.Guo,M.J.Guo,R.P.Guo,Y.P.Guo,A.Guskov,J.Gutierrez,K.L.Han,T.T.Han,F.Hanisch,X.Q.Hao,F.A.Harris,K.K.He,K.L.He,F.H.Heinsius,C.H.Heinz,Y.K.Heng,C.Herold,T.Holtmann,P.C.Hong,G.Y.Hou,X.T.Hou,Y.R.Hou,Z.L.Hou,B.Y.Hu,H.M.Hu,J.F.Hu,Q.P.Hu,S.L.Hu,T.Hu,Y.Hu,G.S.Huang,K.X.Huang,L.Q.Huang,X.T.Huang,Y.P.Huang,Y.S.Huang,T.Hussain,F.Hölzken,N.Hüsken,N.in der Wiesche,J.Jackson,S.Janchiv,J.H.Jeong,Q.Ji,Q.P.Ji,W.Ji,X.B.Ji,X.L.Ji,Y.Y.Ji,X.Q.Jia,Z.K.Jia,D.Jiang,H.B.Jiang,P.C.Jiang,S.S.Jiang,T.J.Jiang,X.S.Jiang,Y.Jiang,J.B.Jiao,J.K.Jiao,Z.Jiao,S.Jin,Y.Jin,M.Q.Jing,X.M.Jing,T.Johansson,S.Kabana,N.Kalantar-Nayestanaki,X.L.Kang,X.S.Kang,M.Kavatsyuk,B.C.Ke,V.Khachatryan,A.Khoukaz,R.Kiuchi,O.B.Kolcu,B.Kopf,M.Kuessner,X.Kui,N.Kumar,A.Kupsc,W.Kühn,L.Lavezzi,T.T.Lei,Z.H.Lei,M.Lellmann,T.Lenz,C.Li,C.Li,C.H.Li,Cheng Li,D.M.Li,F.Li,G.Li,H.B.Li,H.J.Li,H.N.Li,Hui Li,J.R.Li,J.S.Li,K.Li,K.L.Li,L.J.Li,L.K.Li,Lei Li,M.H.Li,P.R.Li,Q.M.Li,Q.X.Li,R.Li,S.X.Li,T.Li,T.Y.Li,W.D.Li,W.G.Li,X.Li,X.H.Li,X.L.Li,X.Y.Li,X.Z.Li,Y.G.Li,Z.J.Li,Z.Y.Li,C.Liang,H.Liang,H.Liang,Y.F.Liang,Y.T.Liang,G.R.Liao,Y.P.Liao,J.Libby,A.Limphirat,C.C.Lin,C.X.Lin,D.X.Lin,T.Lin,B.J.Liu,B.X.Liu,C.Liu,C.X.Liu,F.Liu,F.H.Liu,Feng Liu,G.M.Liu,H.Liu,H.B.Liu,H.H.Liu,H.M.Liu,Huihui Liu,J.B.Liu,J.Y.Liu,K.Liu,K.Y.Liu,Ke Liu,L.Liu,L.C.Liu,Lu Liu,M.H.Liu,P.L.Liu,Q.Liu,S.B.Liu,T.Liu,W.K.Liu,W.M.Liu,X.Liu,X.Liu,Y.Liu,Y.Liu,Y.B.Liu,Z.A.Liu,Z.D.Liu,Z.Q.Liu,X.C.Lou,F.X.Lu,H.J.Lu,J.G.Lu,X.L.Lu,Y.Lu,Y.P.Lu,Z.H.Lu,C.L.Luo,J.R.Luo,M.X.Luo,T.Luo,X.L.Luo,X.R.Lyu,Y.F.Lyu,F.C.Ma,H.Ma,H.L.Ma,J.L.Ma,L.L.Ma,L.R.Ma,M.M.Ma,Q.M.Ma,R.Q.Ma,T.Ma,X.T.Ma,X.Y.Ma,Y.M.Ma,F.E.Maas,I.MacKay,M.Maggiora,S.Malde,Y.J.Mao,Z.P.Mao,S.Marcello,Z.X.Meng,J.G.Messchendorp,G.Mezzadri,H.Miao,T.J.Min,R.E.Mitchell,X.H.Mo,B.Moses,N.Yu.Muchnoi,J.Muskalla,Y.Nefedov,F.Nerling,L.S.Nie,I.B.Nikolaev,Z.Ning,S.Nisar,Q.L.Niu,W.D.Niu,Y.Niu,S.L.Olsen,S.L.Olsen,Q.Ouyang,S.Pacetti,X.Pan,Y.Pan,A.Pathak,Y.P.Pei,M.Pelizaeus,H.P.Peng,Y.Y.Peng,K.Peters,J.L.Ping,R.G.Ping,S.Plura,V.Prasad,F.Z.Qi,H.Qi,H.R.Qi,M.Qi,T.Y.Qi,S.Qian,W.B.Qian,C.F.Qiao,X.K.Qiao,J.J.Qin,L.Q.Qin,L.Y.Qin,X.P.Qin,X.S.Qin,Z.H.Qin,J.F.Qiu,Z.H.Qu,C.F.Redmer,K.J.Ren,A.Rivetti,M.Rolo,G.Rong,Ch.Rosner,M.Q.Ruan,S.N.Ruan,N.Salone,A.Sarantsev,Y.Schelhaas,K.Schoenning,M.Scodeggio,K.Y.Shan,W.Shan,X.Y.Shan,Z.J.Shang,J.F.Shangguan,L.G.Shao,M.Shao,C.P.Shen,H.F.Shen,W.H.Shen,X.Y.Shen,B.A.Shi,H.Shi,J.L.Shi,J.Y.Shi,Q.Q.Shi,S.Y.Shi,X.Shi,J.J.Song,T.Z.Song,W.M.Song,Y.J.Song,Y.X.Song,S.Sosio,S.Spataro,F.Stieler,S.S Su,Y.J.Su,G.B.Sun,G.X.Sun,H.Sun,H.K.Sun,J.F.Sun,K.Sun,L.Sun,S.S.Sun,T.Sun,W.Y.Sun,Y.Sun,Y.J.Sun,Y.Z.Sun,Z.Q.Sun,Z.T.Sun,C.J.Tang,G.Y.Tang,J.Tang,J.J.Tang,Y.A.Tang,L.Y.Tao,Q.T.Tao,M.Tat,J.X.Teng,V.Thoren,W.H.Tian,Y.Tian,Z.F.Tian,I.Uman,Y.Wan,S.J.Wang,B.Wang,B.L.Wang,Bo Wang,D.Y.Wang,F.Wang,H.J.Wang,J.J.Wang,J.P.Wang,K.Wang,L.L.Wang,M.Wang,N.Y.Wang,S.Wang,S.Wang,T.Wang,T.J.Wang,W.Wang,W.Wang,W.P.Wang,X.Wang,X.F.Wang,X.J.Wang,X.L.Wang,X.N.Wang,Y.Wang,Y.D.Wang,Y.F.Wang,Y.H.Wang,Y.L.Wang,Y.N.Wang,Y.Q.Wang,Yaqian Wang,Yi Wang,Z.Wang,Z.L.Wang,Z.Y.Wang,Ziyi Wang,D.H.Wei,F.Weidner,S.P.Wen,Y.R.Wen,U.Wiedner,G.Wilkinson,M.Wolke,L.Wollenberg,C.Wu,J.F.Wu,L.H.Wu,L.J.Wu,X.Wu,X.H.Wu,Y.Wu,Y.H.Wu,Y.J.Wu,Z.Wu,L.Xia,X.M.Xian,B.H.Xiang,T.Xiang,D.Xiao,G.Y.Xiao,S.Y.Xiao,Y.L.Xiao,Z.J.Xiao,C.Xie,X.H.Xie,Y.Xie,Y.G.Xie,Y.H.Xie,Z.P.Xie,T.Y.Xing,C.F.Xu,C.J.Xu,G.F.Xu,H.Y.Xu,M.Xu,Q.J.Xu,Q.N.Xu,W.Xu,W.L.Xu,X.P.Xu,Y.Xu,Y.C.Xu,Z.S.Xu,F.Yan,L.Yan,W.B.Yan,W.C.Yan,X.Q.Yan,H.J.Yang,H.L.Yang,H.X.Yang,J.H.Yang,T.Yang,Y.Yang,Y.F.Yang,Y.F.Yang,Y.X.Yang,Z.W.Yang,Z.P.Yao,M.Ye,M.H.Ye,J.H.Yin,Junhao Yin,Z.Y.You,B.X.Yu,C.X.Yu,G.Yu,J.S.Yu,M.C.Yu,T.Yu,X.D.Yu,Y.C.Yu,C.Z.Yuan,J.Yuan,J.Yuan,L.Yuan,S.C.Yuan,Y.Yuan,Z.Y.Yuan,C.X.Yue,A.A.Zafar,F.R.Zeng,S.H.Zeng,X.Zeng,Y.Zeng,Y.J.Zeng,Y.J.Zeng,X.Y.Zhai,Y.C.Zhai,Y.H.Zhan,A.Q.Zhang,B.L.Zhang,B.X.Zhang,D.H.Zhang,G.Y.Zhang,H.Zhang,H.Zhang,H.C.Zhang,H.H.Zhang,H.H.Zhang,H.Q.Zhang,H.R.Zhang,H.Y.Zhang,J.Zhang,J.Zhang,J.J.Zhang,J.L.Zhang,J.Q.Zhang,J.S.Zhang,J.W.Zhang,J.X.Zhang,J.Y.Zhang,J.Z.Zhang,Jianyu Zhang,L.M.Zhang,Lei Zhang,P.Zhang,Q.Y.Zhang,R.Y.Zhang,S.H.Zhang,Shulei Zhang,X.M.Zhang,X.Y Zhang,X.Y.Zhang,Y.Zhang,Y.Zhang,Y.T.Zhang,Y.H.Zhang,Y.M.Zhang,Yan Zhang,Z.D.Zhang,Z.H.Zhang,Z.L.Zhang,Z.Y.Zhang,Z.Y.Zhang,Z.Z.Zhang,G.Zhao,J.Y.Zhao,J.Z.Zhao,L.Zhao,L.Zhao,M.G.Zhao,N.Zhao,R.P.Zhao,S.J.Zhao,Y.B.Zhao,Y.X.Zhao,Z.G.Zhao,A.Zhemchugov,B.Zheng,B.M.Zheng,J.P.Zheng,W.J.Zheng,Y.H.Zheng,B.Zhong,X.Zhong,H.Zhou,J.Y.Zhou,L.P.Zhou,S.Zhou,X.Zhou,X.K.Zhou,X.R.Zhou,X.Y.Zhou,Y.Z.Zhou,Z.C.Zhou,A.N.Zhu,J.Zhu,K.Zhu,K.J.Zhu,K.S.Zhu,L.Zhu,L.X.Zhu,S.H.Zhu,T.J.Zhu,W.D.Zhu,Y.C.Zhu,Z.A.Zhu,J.H.Zou,J.Zu.Precise measurement of the χ_(c 0) resonance parameters and branching fractions ofχ_(c 0,c 2)→π^(+)π^(−)/K^(+)K^(−)[J].Chinese Physics C,2025,49(9):1-11.