摘要
创新多元协同治理模式是应对中国城市更新价值转变与破解发展困局的重要抓手,是推动城市高质量发展的迫切需要。从治理要素的整体协同视角出发,运用案例研究和归纳分析法,以杭州为典型案例,系统解析城市更新协同治理的实践路径与内在机制。结果表明:(1)杭州城市更新形成了统筹管理体制与多元政策工具的治理环境建设、“政府、市场、居民、社会”四心协同的治理结构搭建、“知识—话语”与“实体技术”协同的治理手段应用、“发展、民生、保护”多目标协同的治理结果达成等四条多元协同治理路径。(2)城市更新多元协同治理应是涵盖“协同环境—协同结构—协同手段—协同结果”的整体协同,通过自洽型统筹管理与协调型政策创新的环境协同机制、多元化利益协调与差异化权力配置的结构协同机制、规范性程序驱动与激励性刚弹管控的手段协同机制、冲突性目标共生与差异性全民共享的结果协同机制,实现城市更新高质量发展目标。基于此,提出以责权协调与动态调适为原则,协同创新统筹型管理体制与政策工具;根据角色定位差异化配置主体权力,形成兼容型城市更新治理共同体;以规范与激励为基点,创新刚弹结合的城市更新治理手段;兼顾效率与公平,促进经济、社会、环境等多维目标协调发展等治理启示,为新发展阶段下的城市更新治理提供经验借鉴。
Innovating the multi-stakeholder collaborative governance model is essential for addressing the China's urban renewal and developmental obstacles.It would also assist in promoting high-quality urban development.This study analyzes the practical pathways and internal mechanisms of collaborative governance in urban renewal.With Hangzhou as an example,the study adopts a case study and inductive analysis methods to explore these dynamics.The results indicate that:(1)Hangzhou's urban renewal has developed four governance paths.The first path is building a governance environment through an integrated management system and diverse policy tools.The second path is establishing a governance structure that coordinates the efforts of government,market,residents,and society.The third path is applying governance tools that combine knowledge-based discourse and physical technology.Finally,the fourth path is achieving governance outcomes that balance development,livelihood,and preservation.(2)Multi-stakeholder collaborative governance of urban renewal should encompass an integrated framework of'synergistic environment-structure-means-outcomes.'This includes an environmental synergy through self-consistent management and coordinated policy innovation,a structural synergy via diversified interest coordination and differentiated power allocation,a means synergy through normative procedures and incentive controls,and a results synergy focused on balancing conflicting goals with universal sharing.These integrated mechanisms are designed to facilitate high-quality urban renewal through coordinated development strategies.Therefore,this study offers four key governance insights.Firstly,it highlights the principles of responsibility-rights coordination and dynamic adjustment to innovate management systems and policy tools.Secondly,it calls for allocating stakeholder power based on roles to build an inclusive urban renewal governance community.Thirdly,it proposes combining regulation and incentives for flexible yet effective governance approaches.Finally,it stresses balancing efficiency and equity to achieve coordinated economic,social,and environmental development.These insights provide valuable lessons for advancing urban renewal governance in the New Era.
作者
徐可西
苏婕妤
鲍海君
XU Ke-xi;SU Jie-yu;BAO Hai-jun(School of Spatial Planning and Design,Hangzhou City University,Hangzhou 310015,China;School of Public Administration,Zhejiang University of Finance and Economics,Hangzhou 310018,China)
出处
《自然资源学报》
北大核心
2025年第6期1451-1467,共17页
Journal of Natural Resources
基金
浙江省哲学社会科学规划课题(24SSHZ011YB)
浙江省自然科学基金项目(LY24G030003)
国家自然科学基金项目(42271267)。
关键词
城市更新
实践路径
内在机制
多元协同治理
案例研究
杭州
urban renewal
practical approach
internal mechanism
multi-stakeholder collaboration
case study
Hangzhou
