摘要
面对机械执法、司法的困境,价值入法成了重要的拯救理路。然而,由于没有对价值入法的前提给予足够的关注,出现了思维的含混及实践困难。价值入法的前提是两者的分离。如果没有分离命题,价值入法在逻辑上就不能成立,只有两者的分离才有融入的必要。价值入法是统合思维,而统合是有条件的,不能无原则、无条件的价值入法,否则就会影响法治目标即法律秩序的实现。价值入法需要方法的限定,应以迂回的方式、以法律渊源的名义,把价值“自然”带入法律,不宜直接用价值代替法律。
Facing the dilemma of mechanical law enforcement and judicature,integrating value into law has become an important rescue idea.However,due to insufficient attention to the premise,there are ambiguities in thinking and practical difficulties.The premise is the separation of law and value.If there is no separation proposition,the method of value cannot be established logically.The separation of the two is of necessity.Integrating value into the law is a kind of integrated thinking and the integration is conditional.The value cannot be put into law without principles and conditions;otherwise it will affect the realization of the goal of law,that is,legal order.It needs to be limited by the method,and should be brought into law in a circuitous way and in the name of the legal source,and it is not suitable to replace law with value directly.
作者
陈金钊
CHEN Jinzhao(Legal Method Institute,East China University of Political Science and Law,Shanghai 201620)
出处
《扬州大学学报（人文社会科学版）》
2021年第3期39-53,共15页
Journal of Yangzhou University(Humanities and Social Sciences Edition)
基金
国家社会科学基金重大项目“新兴学科视野中的法律逻辑及其拓展研究”(18ZDA034)。
关键词
法律价值
价值入法
体系思维
法律渊源
法治逻辑
legal value
integrating value into law
systematic thinking
legal source
logic of rule of law
