摘要
以往对量刑失衡问题的法律文本研究主要集中于量刑指导意见和量刑指导意见实施细则,对司法指导性文件尤其是地方司法机关出台的会议纪要并未给予足够的重视。在量刑实务中,尽管司法指导性文件在统一量刑标准的意义上发挥了重要作用,但缺乏规范的司法指导性文件亦可能会加剧量刑失衡,并降低刑罚裁量的公信力。因此,在以司法指导性文件为抓手进行量刑规范化改革的同时,有必要采取一系列有效的治理手段对其进行规范。
In the past,the research on the legal text of the imbalance of sentencing mainly focused on the sentencing guidance and the implementation rules of sentencing guidance,and did not pay enough attention to the judicial guidance documents,especially the minutes of meetings issued by local judicial organs.In sentencing practice,although judicial guidance documents play an important role in the sense of unification of sentencing standards,the lack of normative binding judicial guidance documents may also aggravate the imbalance of sentencing and reduce the credibility of penalty discretion.Therefore,it is necessary to adopt a series of effective governance measures to standardize sentencing while carrying out the reform of sentencing standardization with judicial guidance documents as the grasp.
作者
吴睿佳
王瑞君
Wu Ruijia;Wang Ruijun
出处
《行政与法》
2019年第1期78-89,共12页
Administration and Law
基金
2018年山东省社会科学规划研究重点项目"认罪认罚从宽司法改革疑难问题研究"的阶段性成果
项目编号:18BFXJ04
关键词
量刑失衡
量刑规范化
司法指导性文件
司法解释
unbalanced sentencing
standardization of sentencing
judicial guidance documents
judicial interpretation
