摘要
学术界对杨蕤的博士论文及同名著作赞誉较高。针对祁琛云的批评意见,文章试图从不同学科层面进行再评价,主要涉及历史地理学的写法;历史地理是否可以推断甚至是猜测;多学科的综合运用,该著作开创了西夏问题的研究先例;该著作为西夏的历史地图绘制打下坚实基础;勾勒宋夏时期(中国)西北地区民族格局;深入探讨了西夏农牧业交错分布;重新探讨了西夏灭亡的有关史实等七个方面。文章最后对相关研究进行了总结和展望。
Yang Rui＇s doctoral dissertation The Studies of Xixia Geography and his seminal work of that name have won high reputation in the academic circles.In view of Qi Chenyun＇s criticism,this paper attempts to reevaluate this work from the viewpoints of different disciplines.The comments on the work mainly involve the following seven aspects： the writing style of historical geography;whether the historical geography can be inferred or even supposed;its application of the theory and technology of multi-disciplines and pioneering research of Xixia regime;laying a sound foundation for the historical mapping of Xixia;revealing the situation concerning the ethnic groups in northwest area of China in the period of Song Dynasty and Xixia;exploring the integration of agriculture and animal husbandry in Xixia;reexaminating the facts of the collapse of Xixia regime.The paper also draws some conclusions of the whole study.
出处
《合肥工业大学学报（社会科学版）》
2012年第4期73-78,共6页
Journal of Hefei University of Technology(Social Sciences)
基金
教育部人文社会科学研究项目(09YJCZH084)
北京市属高等学校人才强教深化计划中青年骨干人才资助项目(PHR201108319)
国家社会科学基金项目(10BGL049)
北京市高等教育学会"十二五"高等教育科学研究规划课题(BG125YB012)
关键词
西夏学
历史地理
《西夏地理研究》
Xixiaology
historical geography
The Studies of Xixia Geography
