国外司法介入体育争议之综述被引量：17

Summary of Judicial Intervention in Sports Disputes of Foreign Countries

下载PDF

导出

摘要介绍美国、澳大利亚、英国、德国、瑞士等国家司法机关介入体育争议的方法、性质、原则等情况。认为:国外司法机关的审查通常限制在程序性问题,如裁决的做出是否遵守了公平、正当程序等原则,而且必须是在用尽了体育组织的内部救济后才可以将有关争议提交法院进行审查。面对我国日益增多的体育争议,建议引入司法介入制度。 It introduced the methods, nature, principles etc. of judicial intervention in sports disputes in USA, Australia, Britain, Germany, Switzerland and so on. it holds that the examination of the foreign judicial organs are ordinarily limited to the issues of procedure, for example, whether or not a ruling made cocnplies with the principles of fair and justifiable procedure etc., and the disputes can be submitted to court for examination only when it can＇ t be served by the internal relief of sports organization. Facing to day-by-day increasing sports disputes in our country, it suggests introduction of judicial intervention system.

作者黄世席

机构地区山东大学法学院

出处《上海体育学院学报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2006年第2期12-15,60,共5页 Journal of Shanghai University of Sport

基金国家社会科学基金资助项目(05CTY004)

关键词体育争议司法介入美国澳大利亚英国德国瑞士 sports disputes judicial intervention America Australia Britain Germany Switzerland

分类号 G80-05 [文化科学—运动人体科学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献10

1Marcia B.Nelson.Stuck between Interlocking Rings:Efforts to Resolve the Conflicting Demands Placed on Olympic National Governing Bodies[J].Van.J.Int'l.L.,1993,20(4):895～926.
2Jeffrey M.Schalley.Eliminate Violence from Sports through Arbitration,Not the Civil Courts[J].Sports Law.J.,2001,8(1):181～205.
3Andrew Gibson,Diane Gee-Clough.Australian Sports Law (Loose-leaf)[M].CCH Australia Limited,1999:50 053,50 602,50 202.
4Adam Lewis,Jonathan Taylor.Sport:Law and Practice[M].Great Britain:Butterworths,2003:117～118.
5Simon Gardiner.Sports Law (2nd edition)[M].London:Cavendish Publishing Limited,2001:251,199.
6Steve Greenfield,Guy Osborn.Law and Ssport in Contemporary Society[M].London/Portland:Frank Cass Publishers,2000:87.
7John A.Faylor.The Dismantling of German Champion:Katrin Krabbe and Her Ordeal with the German Track and Field Association and the International Amateur Athletic Federation[J].Arb.Int'l,2001,17(2):163～171.
8Aaron N Wise,Bruce S.Meyer.International Sports Law and Business[M].The Hague:Kluwer Law International,1997:1 419,1 280～1281.
9John Barnes.Sports and the Law in Canada (3rd edition)[M].Toronto:Butterworths,1996:77～78.
10方益波,杨明.足协提出管辖权异议:司法不能介入体育纠纷[EB/OL].http://sports.china.com/zh_cn/sportsnews/chinasoccer/1040/20020101/10183767.html,2003-12-20.