摘要
理论界一直对违反行政程序的法律责任众说纷纭,在实务操作上更是莫衷一是。违反行政程序需要承担法律责任,问题的关键是如何认定行政程序违法的标准,本文认为除了法定程序标准外,我国还应引进正当程序标准,此外,对行政机关违反其所作出的有关程序的承诺的行为,也应认定为违法。对违反行政程序的行政行为,法院应根据提起行政诉讼的原告主体身份的差异以及行政程序的重要性程度,作出不同的判决,如果行政行为因程序违法而被撤销,行政机关不得重新作出相同或相似行为,并且行政机关应当对其违反行政程序的行为承担相应的国家赔偿责任。
Violation of administrative procedure has been always a complicated questions both in theoretical field and practical field and so dose the legal liability of it. The first question is the standards of violating administrative procedure and the article defines the border of legal procedure and suggests we should input Due Process Furthermore, if the government betrays its own promise although not its actions, it also should take on corresponding legal liability. Finally, the article make asthe conclusion that the court should have different judgments according to the different status of plaintiff and the importance of the procedures and require the government not to make same or semiliar action as the before action.
出处
《国家行政学院学报》
CSSCI
2005年第3期63-66,共4页
Journal of China National School of Administration
关键词
行政程序违法
认定标准
法律后果
行政法律责任
violation of administrative procedure
standards
legal consequence
legal administrative liability
