摘要
本文是针对"鉴定结论必须明确"的立法建议和"鉴定结论必须准确"的鉴定工作发展目标提出的质疑。认为"鉴定结论必须明确"不符合提供证据的法律要求,以六条理由论证这一建议不宜采纳,主张以"鉴定结论应当符合科学技术标准"作为对鉴定结论的立法要求。文中以五条依据分析"鉴定必准"是一个难以实现的工作目标,主张"鉴定结论应当客观真实"才具有可行性,才符合证据规范。
Questioning about the legislation suggestion of 'appraisal result must be clear' and the forensic science goal of 'appraisal result must be accurate', this paper argues, supported by six implicit reasons, that the 'appraisal result must be clear' is not compliant with the legal requirements of evidence providing, and it should be modified to 'appraisal result should meet the science and technology standards'. Explaining the goal of 'appraisal result must be clear' is impractical, the author thinks this should be changed into standard-compliant and more practical goal of 'appraisal result should be objective and true'.
出处
《证据科学》
2007年第5期90-96,共7页
Evidence Science
关键词
鉴定结论
证据要求
客观真实
证据要求
科学技术标准
Appraisal result, Evidence requirements, Objective and true, Science and technology standard
