Purpose： First, to review the state-of-the-art in patent citation analysis, particularly characteristics of patent citations to scientific literature （scientific non-patent references, SNPRs）. Second, to present a ...Purpose： First, to review the state-of-the-art in patent citation analysis, particularly characteristics of patent citations to scientific literature （scientific non-patent references, SNPRs）. Second, to present a novel mapping approach to identify technology-relevant research based on the papers cited by and referring to the SNPRs. Design/methodology/approach： In the review part we discuss the context of SNPRs such as the time lags between scientific achievements and inventions. Also patent-to-patent citation is addressed particularly because this type of patent citation analysis is a major element in the assessment of the economic value of patents. We also review the research on the role of universities and researchers in technological development, with important issues such as universities as sources of technological knowledge and inventor-author relations. We conclude the review part of this paper with an overview of recent research on mapping and network analysis of the science and technology interface and of technological progress in interaction with science. In the second part we apply new techniques for the direct visualization of the cited and citing relations of SNPRs, the mapping of the landscape around SNPRs by bibliographic coupling and co-citation analysis, and the mapping of the conceptual environment of SNPRs by keyword co-occurrence analysis. Findings： We discuss several properties of SNPRs. Only a small minority of publications covered by the Web of Science or Scopus are cited by patents, about 3%-4%. However, for publications based on university-industry collaboration the number of SNPRs is considerably higher, around 15%. The proposed mapping methodology based on a ＂second order SNPR approach＂ enables a better assessment of the technological relevance of research. Research limitations： The main limitation is that a more advanced merging of patent and publication data, in particular unification of author and inventor names, in still a necessity. Practical implications： The proposed mapping methodology enables the creation of a database of technology-relevant papers （TRPs）. In a bibliometric assessment the publications of research groups, research programs or institutes can be matched with the TRPs and thus the extent to which the work of groups, programs or institutes are relevant for technological development can be measured. Originality/value： The review part examines a wide range of findings in the research of patent citation analysis. The mapping approach to identify a broad range of technologyrelevant papers is novel and offers new opportunities in research evaluation practices.展开更多
The evaluation of academic researchers often relies on quantitative metrics,despite their limitations.This paper examines the qualitative assessment approach used by the French National Center for Scientific Research(...The evaluation of academic researchers often relies on quantitative metrics,despite their limitations.This paper examines the qualitative assessment approach used by the French National Center for Scientific Research(CNRS)in Computer Science(Section 6),as presented by a National Committee for Scientific Research(CoNRS)committee president.Rejecting bibliometrics like impact factors,CNRS emphasizes in-depth peer review of research quality,diverse outputs(e.g.,software and datasets),and field-specific considerations.The process,aligned with the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment(DORA),faces challenges in scalability and subjectivity,addressed through committee diversity and structured deliberation.This work provides insights for institutions seeking fairer,more holistic research evaluation frameworks.展开更多
Social network analysis(SNA) has been introduced to China's Mainland since the end of last century. It is often stated that SNA research has experienced rapid growth in China over these years, but few studies have...Social network analysis(SNA) has been introduced to China's Mainland since the end of last century. It is often stated that SNA research has experienced rapid growth in China over these years, but few studies have been conducted to prove the statement. This paper aims at exploring the research status and development of SNA in China by a critical assessment of journal articles. Our findings show that SNA is an evolving and diversified research area which has rich themes and topics, and can be applied to those studies on different levels, context and disciplines, and attract researchers and scholars from various fields and domains. In addition, the information community(Library & Information Science and Information Systems) plays a leading role in the SNA related researches. The paper also points out the research on SNA in China has some limitations, so it proposes several implications for the future development of SNA research from perspectives of information science.展开更多
On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rank...On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rankings:Chinese University Ranking,Chinese Graduate School Ranking,World University Ranking and Scholarly Journal Ranking.The annual reports of all these four rankings are published bythe Science Press,which have been recognized by the academia and China's government.展开更多
Purpose:Citation-based assessments of countries’research capabilities often misrepresent their ability to achieve breakthrough advancements.These assessments commonly classify Japan as a developing country,which cont...Purpose:Citation-based assessments of countries’research capabilities often misrepresent their ability to achieve breakthrough advancements.These assessments commonly classify Japan as a developing country,which contradicts its prominent scientific standing.The purpose of this study is to investigate the underlying causes of such inaccurate assessments and to propose methods for conducting more reliable evaluations.Design/methodology/approach:The study evaluates the effectiveness of top-percentile citation metrics as indicators of breakthrough research.Using case studies of selected countries and research topics,the study examines how deviations from lognormal citation distributions impact the accuracy of these percentile indicators.A similar analysis is conducted using university data from the Leiden Ranking to investigate citation distribution deviations at the institutional level.Findings:The study finds that inflated lower tails in citation distributions lead to undervaluation of research capabilities in advanced technological countries,as captured by some percentile indicators.Conversely,research-intensive universities exhibit the opposite trend:a reduced lower tail relative to the upper tail,which causes percentile indicators to overestimate their actual research capacity.Research limitations:The descriptions are mathematical facts that are self-evident.Practical implications:The ratios between the number of papers in the global top 10%and 1%by citation count to the total number of papers are commonly used to describe research performance.However,due to variations in citation patterns across countries and institutions with reference to the global pattern,these ratios can be misleading and lose their value as research indicators.Originality/value:Size-independent research performance indicators,obtained as the ratios between paper counts in top percentiles and the total numbers of publications,are widely used by public and private institutions.This study demonstrates that the use of these ratios for research evaluations and country rankings can be highly misleading.展开更多
This paper introduces concepts related to scientific research achievements, analyzes current evaluation methods with regard to nursing research achievements and their application at home and abroad, and summarizes fin...This paper introduces concepts related to scientific research achievements, analyzes current evaluation methods with regard to nursing research achievements and their application at home and abroad, and summarizes findings from the investigation of obstacles to the application of nursing research results in China, aiming to provide reference points for the evaluation and application of nursing research results in China.展开更多
Special axle wheel for motor vehicle inspection is an indispensable special weighing instrument in the process of actual inspection of motor vehicles. This kind of detector belongs to non-automatic weighing instrument...Special axle wheel for motor vehicle inspection is an indispensable special weighing instrument in the process of actual inspection of motor vehicles. This kind of detector belongs to non-automatic weighing instrument, and certain problems will inevitably occur in the actual use process. At present, with the continuous improvement of social economy in our country, the production and ownership of automobiles are in the process of rapid development, and the safety performance of automobiles has also received increasing attention. However, the actual inspection of the axle wheel weight gauge is mainly to check whether the braking force of the motor vehicle can meet the corresponding standard, which plays a very important role in ensuring the safety performance of the whole vehicle. In recent years, relevant motor vehicle safety inspection agencies have used various inspection standards, from the initial GB 21861-2014, GB 7258-2017 safety inspection standard and GB 18565-2016 comprehensive inspection standard to the current revision of GB 3847-2018 and GB 18285-2018 environmental inspection standards. With the continuous revision of comprehensive inspection standards, the demand for talents of relevant motor vehicle safety inspection agencies is getting higher and higher. Only when the comprehensive ability of relevant staff is continuously improved, can they better deal with the inaccurate and unreliable inspection results of motor vehicle safety inspection agencies. Based on this, this paper studies the evaluation of measurement uncertainty of indication value of special axle (wheel) gravimeter for motor vehicle testing, for reference.展开更多
A new establishment of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS), the Evaluation Research Center, was officially inaugurated on September 20 in Beijing. Affiliated to the CAS
Google Gemini 1.5 Flash scores were compared with ChatGPT 4o-mini on evaluations of(a)51 of the author’s journal articles and(b)up to 200 articles in each of 34 field-based Units of Assessment(UoAs)from the UK Resear...Google Gemini 1.5 Flash scores were compared with ChatGPT 4o-mini on evaluations of(a)51 of the author’s journal articles and(b)up to 200 articles in each of 34 field-based Units of Assessment(UoAs)from the UK Research Excellence Framework(REF)2021.From(a),the results suggest that Gemini 1.5 Flash,unlike ChatGPT 4o-mini,may work better when fed with a PDF or article full text,rather than just the title and abstract.From(b),Gemini 1.5 Flash seems to be marginally less able to predict an article’s research quality(using a departmental quality proxy indicator)than ChatGPT 4o-mini,although the differences are small,and both have similar disciplinary variations in this ability.Averaging multiple runs of Gemini 1.5 Flash improves the scores.展开更多
This study investigates the application of smart building technology in museum architecture and proposes a corresponding evaluation system.It focuses on three main aspects:first,the integration of smart building techn...This study investigates the application of smart building technology in museum architecture and proposes a corresponding evaluation system.It focuses on three main aspects:first,the integration of smart building technologies in museum facilities,including power supply and distribution,security,and intelligent monitoring systems,which capable to enhance operational efficiency and user experience;second,the role of architectural design in exhibition layout,HVAC systems,and energy-saving measures to optimize energy use and environmental adaptability;and third,the use of information technologies like data management and virtual displays to improve museum management and service quality.The study aims to develop a scientific evaluation framework to assist decision-makers and architects in effectively assessing and selecting smart technologies for museum buildings.By optimizing design and operations,this approach seeks to enhance exhibition quality,resource utilization,and visitor satisfaction,thereby promoting the advancement of the museum industry.展开更多
1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi Uni...1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi University in 2017.Prof.Junping Qiu,a well-known Chinese bibliometrican who has expertise in evaluation management and subsidized by the State Council of China,is the founder and the first president of CASEE.Under the leadership of Prof.Qiu,the CASEE attempts to achieve the following objectives.展开更多
consists of forecasting for the total reserves of regional mineral resources and evaluation,compreIn general,based on evaluated objects and factors involved,evaluation of mineral resources hensive evaluation of region...consists of forecasting for the total reserves of regional mineral resources and evaluation,compreIn general,based on evaluated objects and factors involved,evaluation of mineral resources hensive evaluation of regional mineral resources, and economic and technical evaluation of deposits. Here a region can be a country, a province, or a mining area, while a deposit is mainly related to a single type of mineral, although it can contain more than one types of minerals. In the past, to assess mineral resources was primarily to evaluate and forecast the total reserves of regional mineral resources. With the advancement of science, technology, and economy, the evaluation of mineral resources has developed from forecasting the reserves of them to comprehensively evaluating them on the basis of numerous factors.展开更多
From July 14 to 16,2025,the 16th National Conference on Scientometrics and Science&Education Evaluation was successfully held in Lanzhou.The conference was hosted by Chinese Society for Science of Science and Scie...From July 14 to 16,2025,the 16th National Conference on Scientometrics and Science&Education Evaluation was successfully held in Lanzhou.The conference was hosted by Chinese Society for Science of Science and Science&Technology Policy,Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation at Hangzhou Dianzi University,and China Research Center for Science Evaluation at Wuhan University.展开更多
This paper proposes a holistic framework for the development of models for the assessment of research activities and their impacts. It distinguishes three dimensions, including in an original way, data as a main dimen...This paper proposes a holistic framework for the development of models for the assessment of research activities and their impacts. It distinguishes three dimensions, including in an original way, data as a main dimension, together with theory and methodology. Each dimension of the framework is further characterized by three main building blocks： education, research, and innovation （theory）; efficiency, effectiveness, and impact （methodology）; and availability, interoperability, and ＂unit-free＂ property （data）. The different dimensions and their nine constituent building blocks are attributes of an overarching concept, denoted as ＂quality.＂ Three additional quality attributes are identified as implementation factors （tailorability, transparency, and openness） and three ＂enabling＂ conditions （convergence, mixed methods, and knowledge infrastructures） complete the fi-amework. A framework is required to develop models of metrics. Models of metrics are necessary to assess the meaning, validity, and robustness of metrics. The proposed framework can be a useful reference for the development of the ethics of research evaluation. It can act as a common denominator for different analytical levels and relevant aspects and is able to embrace many different and heterogeneous streams of literature. Directions for future research are provided.展开更多
Purpose： This paper presents findings of a quasi-experimental assessment to gauge the research productivity and degree of interdisciplinarity of research center outputs. Of special interest, we share an enriched visu...Purpose： This paper presents findings of a quasi-experimental assessment to gauge the research productivity and degree of interdisciplinarity of research center outputs. Of special interest, we share an enriched visualization of research co-authoring patterns. Design/methodology/approach： We compile publications by 45 researchers in each of 1） the iUTAH project, which we consider here to be analogous to a ＂research center,＂ 2） CG1-a comparison group of participants in two other Utah environmental research centers, and 3） CG2--a comparison group of Utah university environmental researchers not associated with a research center. We draw bibliometric data from Web of Science and from Google Scholar. We gather publications for a period before iUTAH had been established （2010-2012） and a period after （2014-2016）. We compare these research outputs in terms of publications and citations thereto. We also measure interdisciplinarity using Integration scoring and generate science overlay maps to locate the research publications across disciplines. Findings： We find that participation in the iUTAH project appears to increase research outputs （publications in the After period） and increase research citation rates relative to the comparison group researchers （although CG 1 research remains most cited, as it was in the Before period）. Most notably, participation in iUTAH markedly increases co-authoring among researchers--in general; and for junior, as well as senior, faculty; for men and women： across organizations; and across disciplines. Research limitations： The quasi-experimental design necessarily generates suggestive, not definitively causal, findings because of the imperfect controls. Practical implications： This study demonstrates a viable approach for research assessment of a center or program for which random assignment of control groups is not possible. It illustrates use of bibliometric indicators to inform R＆D program management. Originality/value： New visualizations of researcher collaboration provide compelling comparisons of the extent and nature of social networking among target cohorts.展开更多
Purpose： The main goal of this study is to provide reliable comparison of performance in higher education. In this respect, we use scientometric measures associated with faculties of medicine in the six health studie...Purpose： The main goal of this study is to provide reliable comparison of performance in higher education. In this respect, we use scientometric measures associated with faculties of medicine in the six health studies universities in Romania.Design/methodology/approach： The method to estimate the minimum necessary size, proposed in in Shen et al.（2017）, is applied in this article. We collected data from the Scopus data-base for the academics of the departments of medicine within the six health studies universities in Romania during the 2009 to 2014. And two kind of statistic treatments based on that method are implemented, pair-wise comparison and one-to-the-rest comparison. All the results of these comparisons are shown.Findings： According to the results： We deem that Cluj and Tg. Mure？ have the superior and inferior performance respectively, since their reasonably small value of the minimum representative size, in either of the kinds of comparison, whichever indexes of citations, h-index, or g-index is used. we can not reliably distinguish differences among the rest of the faculties, since the quite large value of their minimum representative size.Research limitations： There is only six faculties of medicine in health studies universities in Romania are analyzed.Practical implications： Our methods of comparison play an important role in ranking data sets associated with different collective units, such as faculties, universities, institutions, based on some aggregate scores like mean and totality. Originality/value： We applied the minimum representative size to a new emprical context- that of the departments of medicine in the health studies universities in Romania.展开更多
On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rank...On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rankings:Chinese University Ranking,Chinese Graduate School Ranking,World University Ranking and Scholarly Journal Ranking.The annual reports of all these four rankings are published bythe Science Press,which have been recognized by the academia and China's government.展开更多
Based on the data of 13 eco-environmental indicators of 14 prefecture level cities in Hunan Province from 2014 to 2018,this paper quantitatively evaluated the eco-environmental competitiveness and its advantages and d...Based on the data of 13 eco-environmental indicators of 14 prefecture level cities in Hunan Province from 2014 to 2018,this paper quantitatively evaluated the eco-environmental competitiveness and its advantages and disadvantages by principal component analysis(PCA).The results showed that:(1)the overall ecoenvironmental competitiveness of Hunan Province was relatively high,whereas the competitiveness level of each city and prefecture was quite different.The comprehensive score of eco-environmental competitiveness of Changsha City was 2.96,ranking the first,and Zhangjiajie city ranking the last with a score of-1.60,which indicated that there was an obvious difference in the level of eco-environmental competitiveness among different regions.(2)The overall eco-environmental competitiveness of cities and prefectures in Western Hunan Province was weak.Among the 14 prefectures and cities in Hunan Province,the comprehensive scores of eco-environmental competitiveness of 6 prefectures and cities were negative,whereas the scores of Zhangjiajie,Xiangxi and Huaihua in Western Hunan were all lower than the others.In the face of increasingly serious environmental problems,cities and prefectures should adjust measures according to local conditions and put forward specific measures to enhance environmental competitiveness.In particular,cities and prefectures in Western Hunan should give full play to their advantages in ecological resources,take the path of green development,enhance the competitiveness of ecological environment,and provide support for local economic development.展开更多
The scientific literature presents a modest amount ot evidence m the use or complementary ana al[erna- tire medicine （CAM）. On the other hand, in practice, relevant results are common. The debates among CAM practiti...The scientific literature presents a modest amount ot evidence m the use or complementary ana al[erna- tire medicine （CAM）. On the other hand, in practice, relevant results are common. The debates among CAM practitioners about the quality and execution of scientific research are important, Therefore, the aim of this review is to gather, synthesize and describe the differentiated methodological models that encompass the complexity of therapeutic interventions. The process of bringing evidence-based medicine into clinical practice in CAM is essential for the growth and strengthening of complementary medicines worldwide.展开更多
1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi Uni...1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi University in 2017.Prof.展开更多
文摘Purpose： First, to review the state-of-the-art in patent citation analysis, particularly characteristics of patent citations to scientific literature （scientific non-patent references, SNPRs）. Second, to present a novel mapping approach to identify technology-relevant research based on the papers cited by and referring to the SNPRs. Design/methodology/approach： In the review part we discuss the context of SNPRs such as the time lags between scientific achievements and inventions. Also patent-to-patent citation is addressed particularly because this type of patent citation analysis is a major element in the assessment of the economic value of patents. We also review the research on the role of universities and researchers in technological development, with important issues such as universities as sources of technological knowledge and inventor-author relations. We conclude the review part of this paper with an overview of recent research on mapping and network analysis of the science and technology interface and of technological progress in interaction with science. In the second part we apply new techniques for the direct visualization of the cited and citing relations of SNPRs, the mapping of the landscape around SNPRs by bibliographic coupling and co-citation analysis, and the mapping of the conceptual environment of SNPRs by keyword co-occurrence analysis. Findings： We discuss several properties of SNPRs. Only a small minority of publications covered by the Web of Science or Scopus are cited by patents, about 3%-4%. However, for publications based on university-industry collaboration the number of SNPRs is considerably higher, around 15%. The proposed mapping methodology based on a ＂second order SNPR approach＂ enables a better assessment of the technological relevance of research. Research limitations： The main limitation is that a more advanced merging of patent and publication data, in particular unification of author and inventor names, in still a necessity. Practical implications： The proposed mapping methodology enables the creation of a database of technology-relevant papers （TRPs）. In a bibliometric assessment the publications of research groups, research programs or institutes can be matched with the TRPs and thus the extent to which the work of groups, programs or institutes are relevant for technological development can be measured. Originality/value： The review part examines a wide range of findings in the research of patent citation analysis. The mapping approach to identify a broad range of technologyrelevant papers is novel and offers new opportunities in research evaluation practices.
文摘The evaluation of academic researchers often relies on quantitative metrics,despite their limitations.This paper examines the qualitative assessment approach used by the French National Center for Scientific Research(CNRS)in Computer Science(Section 6),as presented by a National Committee for Scientific Research(CoNRS)committee president.Rejecting bibliometrics like impact factors,CNRS emphasizes in-depth peer review of research quality,diverse outputs(e.g.,software and datasets),and field-specific considerations.The process,aligned with the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment(DORA),faces challenges in scalability and subjectivity,addressed through committee diversity and structured deliberation.This work provides insights for institutions seeking fairer,more holistic research evaluation frameworks.
基金jointly supported by the National Social Science Foundation in China(Grand No.10ATQ004)Ministry of Education,Humanities and Social Sciences Council in China(Grand No.09YJA870014)
文摘Social network analysis(SNA) has been introduced to China's Mainland since the end of last century. It is often stated that SNA research has experienced rapid growth in China over these years, but few studies have been conducted to prove the statement. This paper aims at exploring the research status and development of SNA in China by a critical assessment of journal articles. Our findings show that SNA is an evolving and diversified research area which has rich themes and topics, and can be applied to those studies on different levels, context and disciplines, and attract researchers and scholars from various fields and domains. In addition, the information community(Library & Information Science and Information Systems) plays a leading role in the SNA related researches. The paper also points out the research on SNA in China has some limitations, so it proposes several implications for the future development of SNA research from perspectives of information science.
文摘On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rankings:Chinese University Ranking,Chinese Graduate School Ranking,World University Ranking and Scholarly Journal Ranking.The annual reports of all these four rankings are published bythe Science Press,which have been recognized by the academia and China's government.
文摘Purpose:Citation-based assessments of countries’research capabilities often misrepresent their ability to achieve breakthrough advancements.These assessments commonly classify Japan as a developing country,which contradicts its prominent scientific standing.The purpose of this study is to investigate the underlying causes of such inaccurate assessments and to propose methods for conducting more reliable evaluations.Design/methodology/approach:The study evaluates the effectiveness of top-percentile citation metrics as indicators of breakthrough research.Using case studies of selected countries and research topics,the study examines how deviations from lognormal citation distributions impact the accuracy of these percentile indicators.A similar analysis is conducted using university data from the Leiden Ranking to investigate citation distribution deviations at the institutional level.Findings:The study finds that inflated lower tails in citation distributions lead to undervaluation of research capabilities in advanced technological countries,as captured by some percentile indicators.Conversely,research-intensive universities exhibit the opposite trend:a reduced lower tail relative to the upper tail,which causes percentile indicators to overestimate their actual research capacity.Research limitations:The descriptions are mathematical facts that are self-evident.Practical implications:The ratios between the number of papers in the global top 10%and 1%by citation count to the total number of papers are commonly used to describe research performance.However,due to variations in citation patterns across countries and institutions with reference to the global pattern,these ratios can be misleading and lose their value as research indicators.Originality/value:Size-independent research performance indicators,obtained as the ratios between paper counts in top percentiles and the total numbers of publications,are widely used by public and private institutions.This study demonstrates that the use of these ratios for research evaluations and country rankings can be highly misleading.
基金supported by Shanxi Province Health Department of scientific and technological projects(No.2013010008)
文摘This paper introduces concepts related to scientific research achievements, analyzes current evaluation methods with regard to nursing research achievements and their application at home and abroad, and summarizes findings from the investigation of obstacles to the application of nursing research results in China, aiming to provide reference points for the evaluation and application of nursing research results in China.
文摘Special axle wheel for motor vehicle inspection is an indispensable special weighing instrument in the process of actual inspection of motor vehicles. This kind of detector belongs to non-automatic weighing instrument, and certain problems will inevitably occur in the actual use process. At present, with the continuous improvement of social economy in our country, the production and ownership of automobiles are in the process of rapid development, and the safety performance of automobiles has also received increasing attention. However, the actual inspection of the axle wheel weight gauge is mainly to check whether the braking force of the motor vehicle can meet the corresponding standard, which plays a very important role in ensuring the safety performance of the whole vehicle. In recent years, relevant motor vehicle safety inspection agencies have used various inspection standards, from the initial GB 21861-2014, GB 7258-2017 safety inspection standard and GB 18565-2016 comprehensive inspection standard to the current revision of GB 3847-2018 and GB 18285-2018 environmental inspection standards. With the continuous revision of comprehensive inspection standards, the demand for talents of relevant motor vehicle safety inspection agencies is getting higher and higher. Only when the comprehensive ability of relevant staff is continuously improved, can they better deal with the inaccurate and unreliable inspection results of motor vehicle safety inspection agencies. Based on this, this paper studies the evaluation of measurement uncertainty of indication value of special axle (wheel) gravimeter for motor vehicle testing, for reference.
文摘A new establishment of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS), the Evaluation Research Center, was officially inaugurated on September 20 in Beijing. Affiliated to the CAS
文摘Google Gemini 1.5 Flash scores were compared with ChatGPT 4o-mini on evaluations of(a)51 of the author’s journal articles and(b)up to 200 articles in each of 34 field-based Units of Assessment(UoAs)from the UK Research Excellence Framework(REF)2021.From(a),the results suggest that Gemini 1.5 Flash,unlike ChatGPT 4o-mini,may work better when fed with a PDF or article full text,rather than just the title and abstract.From(b),Gemini 1.5 Flash seems to be marginally less able to predict an article’s research quality(using a departmental quality proxy indicator)than ChatGPT 4o-mini,although the differences are small,and both have similar disciplinary variations in this ability.Averaging multiple runs of Gemini 1.5 Flash improves the scores.
基金Jiangxi Province Intelligent Building Engineering Research Center Open Fund Project(Project No.:EZ202311417).
文摘This study investigates the application of smart building technology in museum architecture and proposes a corresponding evaluation system.It focuses on three main aspects:first,the integration of smart building technologies in museum facilities,including power supply and distribution,security,and intelligent monitoring systems,which capable to enhance operational efficiency and user experience;second,the role of architectural design in exhibition layout,HVAC systems,and energy-saving measures to optimize energy use and environmental adaptability;and third,the use of information technologies like data management and virtual displays to improve museum management and service quality.The study aims to develop a scientific evaluation framework to assist decision-makers and architects in effectively assessing and selecting smart technologies for museum buildings.By optimizing design and operations,this approach seeks to enhance exhibition quality,resource utilization,and visitor satisfaction,thereby promoting the advancement of the museum industry.
文摘1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi University in 2017.Prof.Junping Qiu,a well-known Chinese bibliometrican who has expertise in evaluation management and subsidized by the State Council of China,is the founder and the first president of CASEE.Under the leadership of Prof.Qiu,the CASEE attempts to achieve the following objectives.
文摘consists of forecasting for the total reserves of regional mineral resources and evaluation,compreIn general,based on evaluated objects and factors involved,evaluation of mineral resources hensive evaluation of regional mineral resources, and economic and technical evaluation of deposits. Here a region can be a country, a province, or a mining area, while a deposit is mainly related to a single type of mineral, although it can contain more than one types of minerals. In the past, to assess mineral resources was primarily to evaluate and forecast the total reserves of regional mineral resources. With the advancement of science, technology, and economy, the evaluation of mineral resources has developed from forecasting the reserves of them to comprehensively evaluating them on the basis of numerous factors.
文摘From July 14 to 16,2025,the 16th National Conference on Scientometrics and Science&Education Evaluation was successfully held in Lanzhou.The conference was hosted by Chinese Society for Science of Science and Science&Technology Policy,Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation at Hangzhou Dianzi University,and China Research Center for Science Evaluation at Wuhan University.
基金financial support of the Italian Ministry of Education and Research(through the PRIN Project N.2015RJARX7)Sapienza University of Rome(through the Sapienza Awards no.6H15XNFS)the Lazio Region(through the Project FILAS-RU-2014-1186)
文摘This paper proposes a holistic framework for the development of models for the assessment of research activities and their impacts. It distinguishes three dimensions, including in an original way, data as a main dimension, together with theory and methodology. Each dimension of the framework is further characterized by three main building blocks： education, research, and innovation （theory）; efficiency, effectiveness, and impact （methodology）; and availability, interoperability, and ＂unit-free＂ property （data）. The different dimensions and their nine constituent building blocks are attributes of an overarching concept, denoted as ＂quality.＂ Three additional quality attributes are identified as implementation factors （tailorability, transparency, and openness） and three ＂enabling＂ conditions （convergence, mixed methods, and knowledge infrastructures） complete the fi-amework. A framework is required to develop models of metrics. Models of metrics are necessary to assess the meaning, validity, and robustness of metrics. The proposed framework can be a useful reference for the development of the ethics of research evaluation. It can act as a common denominator for different analytical levels and relevant aspects and is able to embrace many different and heterogeneous streams of literature. Directions for future research are provided.
基金The five-year "innovative Urban Transitions and Aridregion Hydro-sustainability" (iUTAH) project was initiated in 2012 with support from the US National Science Foundation’s (NSF) "Established Program to Stimulate Competitive Research" (EPSCo R, award # OIA-1208732)
文摘Purpose： This paper presents findings of a quasi-experimental assessment to gauge the research productivity and degree of interdisciplinarity of research center outputs. Of special interest, we share an enriched visualization of research co-authoring patterns. Design/methodology/approach： We compile publications by 45 researchers in each of 1） the iUTAH project, which we consider here to be analogous to a ＂research center,＂ 2） CG1-a comparison group of participants in two other Utah environmental research centers, and 3） CG2--a comparison group of Utah university environmental researchers not associated with a research center. We draw bibliometric data from Web of Science and from Google Scholar. We gather publications for a period before iUTAH had been established （2010-2012） and a period after （2014-2016）. We compare these research outputs in terms of publications and citations thereto. We also measure interdisciplinarity using Integration scoring and generate science overlay maps to locate the research publications across disciplines. Findings： We find that participation in the iUTAH project appears to increase research outputs （publications in the After period） and increase research citation rates relative to the comparison group researchers （although CG 1 research remains most cited, as it was in the Before period）. Most notably, participation in iUTAH markedly increases co-authoring among researchers--in general; and for junior, as well as senior, faculty; for men and women： across organizations; and across disciplines. Research limitations： The quasi-experimental design necessarily generates suggestive, not definitively causal, findings because of the imperfect controls. Practical implications： This study demonstrates a viable approach for research assessment of a center or program for which random assignment of control groups is not possible. It illustrates use of bibliometric indicators to inform R＆D program management. Originality/value： New visualizations of researcher collaboration provide compelling comparisons of the extent and nature of social networking among target cohorts.
文摘Purpose： The main goal of this study is to provide reliable comparison of performance in higher education. In this respect, we use scientometric measures associated with faculties of medicine in the six health studies universities in Romania.Design/methodology/approach： The method to estimate the minimum necessary size, proposed in in Shen et al.（2017）, is applied in this article. We collected data from the Scopus data-base for the academics of the departments of medicine within the six health studies universities in Romania during the 2009 to 2014. And two kind of statistic treatments based on that method are implemented, pair-wise comparison and one-to-the-rest comparison. All the results of these comparisons are shown.Findings： According to the results： We deem that Cluj and Tg. Mure？ have the superior and inferior performance respectively, since their reasonably small value of the minimum representative size, in either of the kinds of comparison, whichever indexes of citations, h-index, or g-index is used. we can not reliably distinguish differences among the rest of the faculties, since the quite large value of their minimum representative size.Research limitations： There is only six faculties of medicine in health studies universities in Romania are analyzed.Practical implications： Our methods of comparison play an important role in ranking data sets associated with different collective units, such as faculties, universities, institutions, based on some aggregate scores like mean and totality. Originality/value： We applied the minimum representative size to a new emprical context- that of the departments of medicine in the health studies universities in Romania.
文摘On the basis of research evaluation of Chinese universities,Golden Apple Ranking(GAR)was initiated by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE)at Wuhan University in 2003.The GAR consists of four major rankings:Chinese University Ranking,Chinese Graduate School Ranking,World University Ranking and Scholarly Journal Ranking.The annual reports of all these four rankings are published bythe Science Press,which have been recognized by the academia and China's government.
文摘Based on the data of 13 eco-environmental indicators of 14 prefecture level cities in Hunan Province from 2014 to 2018,this paper quantitatively evaluated the eco-environmental competitiveness and its advantages and disadvantages by principal component analysis(PCA).The results showed that:(1)the overall ecoenvironmental competitiveness of Hunan Province was relatively high,whereas the competitiveness level of each city and prefecture was quite different.The comprehensive score of eco-environmental competitiveness of Changsha City was 2.96,ranking the first,and Zhangjiajie city ranking the last with a score of-1.60,which indicated that there was an obvious difference in the level of eco-environmental competitiveness among different regions.(2)The overall eco-environmental competitiveness of cities and prefectures in Western Hunan Province was weak.Among the 14 prefectures and cities in Hunan Province,the comprehensive scores of eco-environmental competitiveness of 6 prefectures and cities were negative,whereas the scores of Zhangjiajie,Xiangxi and Huaihua in Western Hunan were all lower than the others.In the face of increasingly serious environmental problems,cities and prefectures should adjust measures according to local conditions and put forward specific measures to enhance environmental competitiveness.In particular,cities and prefectures in Western Hunan should give full play to their advantages in ecological resources,take the path of green development,enhance the competitiveness of ecological environment,and provide support for local economic development.
文摘The scientific literature presents a modest amount ot evidence m the use or complementary ana al[erna- tire medicine （CAM）. On the other hand, in practice, relevant results are common. The debates among CAM practitioners about the quality and execution of scientific research are important, Therefore, the aim of this review is to gather, synthesize and describe the differentiated methodological models that encompass the complexity of therapeutic interventions. The process of bringing evidence-based medicine into clinical practice in CAM is essential for the growth and strengthening of complementary medicines worldwide.
文摘1.About CASEE The Chinese Academy of Science and Education Evaluation(CASEE),also known as the Chinese Academy of Evaluation Sciences(CAES),is a key evaluation and research institute established by Hangzhou Dianzi University in 2017.Prof.
