Determining the causal effect of special education is a critical topic when mak-ing educational policy that focuses on student achievement.However,current special education research is facing challenges from persisten...Determining the causal effect of special education is a critical topic when mak-ing educational policy that focuses on student achievement.However,current special education research is facing challenges from persistent selection bias and complex confounding.Bayesian Additive Regression Trees(BART)is em-ployed in this study to provide a flexible estimation of the academic perfor-mance.Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation(TMLE)is also integrated into the BART model,supporting doubly robust estimation of the special ed-ucation effect.This study extracted survey data from the Early Childhood Lon-gitudinal Study,Kindergarten Class(ECLS-K),to estimate the causal impact of special education status on students’combined mathematics and reading achievement scores.The analysis results of the BART-TMLE model show that children receiving special education services demonstrated approximately 9 points lower scores on average for combined math and reading scores,even adjusting for a considerable number of covariates,compared to their peers who did not receive these services.The estimated negative treatment effect persists after controlling for observed covariates that are closely correlated to the combined test score.The negative effect likely reflects unobserved factors,such as the underlying severity of learning disabilities,parent involvement and other potential traits,which are actual factors that determine the placement of special education status,rather than indicating the ineffectiveness of special education service.The achievement gap in academic performance reflects the current observable status of special education.The estimated effect could be improved by future research incorporating educational domain knowledge,allowing the model to be constructed more accurately.展开更多
文摘Determining the causal effect of special education is a critical topic when mak-ing educational policy that focuses on student achievement.However,current special education research is facing challenges from persistent selection bias and complex confounding.Bayesian Additive Regression Trees(BART)is em-ployed in this study to provide a flexible estimation of the academic perfor-mance.Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation(TMLE)is also integrated into the BART model,supporting doubly robust estimation of the special ed-ucation effect.This study extracted survey data from the Early Childhood Lon-gitudinal Study,Kindergarten Class(ECLS-K),to estimate the causal impact of special education status on students’combined mathematics and reading achievement scores.The analysis results of the BART-TMLE model show that children receiving special education services demonstrated approximately 9 points lower scores on average for combined math and reading scores,even adjusting for a considerable number of covariates,compared to their peers who did not receive these services.The estimated negative treatment effect persists after controlling for observed covariates that are closely correlated to the combined test score.The negative effect likely reflects unobserved factors,such as the underlying severity of learning disabilities,parent involvement and other potential traits,which are actual factors that determine the placement of special education status,rather than indicating the ineffectiveness of special education service.The achievement gap in academic performance reflects the current observable status of special education.The estimated effect could be improved by future research incorporating educational domain knowledge,allowing the model to be constructed more accurately.
